The Other Great Debate : Journos V Bloggers

It seems calling a journalist a blogger is like calling an Aussie a Kiwi. You’re far safer to just not do it. Once in a while, someone gets a bee in their bonnet about a label. Whether it’s the SAHM v WM debate, or the “bloggers-aren’t-journalists-aren’t-bloggers” debate, I guess people just need something to talk about. And actually, I do need something to talk about, because blogger’s, journo’s writer’s block is killing me!

I do feel like I’m semi-qualified to comment on this debate, seeing as though I have a degree in journalism, and I have a blog. I actually had a “journal” on LiveJournal and a diary on DiaryLand back before wordpress or blogspot even existed. Granted, I have never written for any publication outside of my university newspaper and the last time I did that was circa 2000. I know media has changed drastically since then. Life has changed drastically since then. Industries have a way of evolving, growing, expanding in directions people don’t expect or anticipate. The media industry is certainly not exempt from that, if anything it may be more susceptible.

Allison Lee, over at The Punch (journalism in its absolute loosest form) has written a piece titled Blogging and Journalism. Not The Same Thing. I’ve read the article. It has stats and figures from a study in it. It’s journalisty. She doesn’t slander bloggers or blogging, she doesn’t, in my opinion, make it sound like she thinks either one is superior. She may make a couple of generalizations about bloggers based on this study (of which there is no reference to how many bloggers were surveyed), but I felt the general point she was trying to make is that blogging and journalism are different. Neither one better, just simply different. And neither one is going away any time soon.

In rebuttal to that piece is Anna Spargo-Ryan, a blogger who says journos and bloggers aren’t as different as we think. Anna has taken Allison’s piece a bit more to heart than I did and argues that bloggers are just as capable of being journalists as journalists are. And, perhaps to the surprise of journos, bloggers do actually care about and are as qualified to write about, current affairs.

I know, opinions are like assholes, we all have one. And lets face it, ours are the only ones that don’t stink. Now there’s a sentence I’m not sure a journo would get away with, but as a blogger, I can use words like asshole. That in itself makes a massive difference between journalism and blogging. I digress.

I think the definition of” journalist” and the definition of “blogger” is very different. More than that, I think it should be different. I could give you Oxford’s definition of each (has blogger made its way into the OED yet?), but I’ll go one step better and give you mine! A journalist typically gathers facts, in an unbiased fashion, to report newsworthy events to a reader/listener base. A blogger typically interprets facts, in an always often-biased fashion, to report events that may or may not be newsworthy to his or her reader base. And they can use fowl language. They can also write about whatever the hell they want to. Journos are assigned stories. In my incredibly limited experience with blogging/bloggers, my guess would be that more of them identify with writers than journalists (yes, there’s a big difference there, too!).

Anna didn’t like Allison alluding to the fact that bloggers only blog about what is going on at the kitchen sink. What I love about bloggers is that they can take something that happens at the kitchen sink and make it a laugh-out-loud story. Something no journalist has ever been able to do with a story out of Canberra. With the exception of that guy on channel 7 who does the weekly political re-cap. He’s quite funny.

I don’t think anyone is saying bloggers can’t report about current affairs and no one is saying journos can’t blog. The very simple bottom line is that blogging is not journalism, and journalism is not blogging. It doesn’t mean they can’t both exist in the same media-driven world. I read news sites because I like to know a little bit about what is going on in the world. I read blogs because I like to identify with other mothers and women who have funny anecdotes, passionate opinions or tragic stories (or a bit of everything).

The truth, for me, is that as a blogger with a journalism degree, I most often feel like neither. I am just a person, who sometimes writes, in a minute (my-newt) part of the interwebs, recording letters to my son, opinions about things I feel passionate about, or just a general bunch of drivel because I have nothing important to say. There are some fantastic bloggers. There are some fantastic journos. There are also some very average ones. It shouldn’t matter what your label is, what you write about, who you write to or who you write for. “Blogger” is not a dirty word. “Journalist” is not an elitist word. Let’s try not to take anything too seriously or too personally, and maybe we’ll all get along just fine.

22 thoughts on “The Other Great Debate : Journos V Bloggers

  1. I am a blogger. I do not write wonderful stories.. I write real life and in my own words. They may not make sense.. but since my fingers type fast, I get out alot of crap thats swirling around in my head…

    I am not a journalist.. I will not report on current affairs.. unless I am standing in the middle of it..

    I love blogging and think more people should do it!

    • I think most bloggers fall into the same category Yvette. And I also think most of us started a blog to keep a record of our growing families, activities, memories. Not to be famous or to be “Journalists”.

  2. Love it. I am me. I just write.
    I don’t care what others think… I’m just me. If they don’t like what I’m saying, they don’t have to read it! 😉

    • That’s the glory of the internet! If you don’t like it, move on, don’t ever visit again! I think we all write for ourselves, and if someone else happens to get something out of it, then that’s the icing on top.

  3. Wow – this is great! Has given me LOTS of things to think about!

    Given that journalism is dying out and online stuff is taking over – the world better get ready for the unqualified journalist coming through commenting on life. That is just my little opinion though.

    • I don’t know if journalism is dying out, but it is certainly evolving and changing from what it used to be. I think “Journalist” is actually starting to be as dirty a word as “lawyer” and I’d say that’s all thanks to the paparazzi and trash news/mags.

  4. I totally agree with you. I just finished a Post-Graduate Diploma in journalism and teachers told us we must have a blog… I think both can co-exist together. Also, if someone want to write in a blog and is just an average writer, well I don’t see what is the problem with that. I don’t understand why some people complain about the fact that if it’s not a good writer well this person should not have a blog. To this people I say: don’t read it you don’t like it. Great piece!

    • Thanks Rita! Of course they can co-exist together. It’s the people behind them that have to make it work. Nothing is impossible. Thanks for your comment.

  5. Well said!
    There is a difference for sure, and I don’t think either I’d better or worse than the others. I guess the difference is that journos general get paid, where as we do it for the love of it. 🙂

    • Yes! Most bloggers do not get paid and do not have massive readerships, etc. I see journalism and blogging as 2 completely different things. Doesn’t’ mean they can’t compliment one another or co-exist. Thanks Jess!

  6. Very well said!
    I love, as a blogger we can be our selves and say it like it is.

    I Love this > “I know, opinions are like assholes, we all have one. And lets face it, ours are the only ones that don’t stink. Now there’s a sentence I’m not sure a journo would get away with, but as a blogger, I can use words like asshole. That in itself makes a massive difference between journalism and blogging.”

  7. I understand your dilemma but I’ve always found it pretty clear. I’m a journo by trade – degree/practice – but I’m also a writer – a blogger – a web logger, which is originally where the term blogging came from (according to my old neighbour – a historian who wrote a book on it years ago). I don’t know if it helps – but anyway, the most important thing you do is enjoy your creative process. That’s what it’s all about – at least for me. ♥

    • Good point – that is the most important thing! We can be and do whatever we choose, and should let others be and do what they choose, too.

  8. Great post! I love how you brought up the point that a label is just that. There will be the great and the not so in both spectrums of blogging and journalism.
    And yes, let’s not take it all so seriously or personally. There’s plenty of room for everyone’s words and stories. It’s up to you how you can engage a reader.

    • Thanks Grace! And some people will like some blogs, others won’t. That’s the great thing about it, if you don’t like it, move along to the next one!

  9. Great post! I’ve not been inclined to read too much of the arguments from either side, mostly due to indifference. I write a blog, but I don’t refer to myself as a blogger. I’m many things that don’t get labelled, so why do I need that one? I write a blog, but I would never consider myself a journalist. To me, a journalist is all those things you mentioned. I’m none of those. I am just a chick who writes a blog, occasionally.

    • Those are the only 2 articles I’ve really read on the subject matter, but it got me wondering why it needed a discussion at all. But I guess that is what blogs/writing/debate/opinions etc are all about? There’s plenty of things I don’t think need discussion but always seem to be hot topics of debate! haha!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s